If a player doesn't pass a physical is a trade voided?

dan

I traded gronk for Witten before gronk failed the physical this week now the guy wants the trade back. Is this right?

greg

If it's a friends league, I'd say give him back. BUT if it's an open league, keep it. It's not like the person can't play Gronk when he finally decides to play. So technically, the trade is valid unless it was only based on them both playing this week. If Witten broke his leg yesterday, would he void the trade? I think not...

legfujohnson

I'd like to see the report from your fantasy football physical.

Gronk has been out all season. Nothing new happened this week.