is "cheesecake" a pie or a cake?

is "cheesecake" a pie or a cake? google was no help

Comments

  • Whether cheesecake should be classified as a cake, a custard, a torte, or something else is a matter of debate.

    The early Greeks, from whom the form originates, considered it a cake. Some modern authors point to the presence of many eggs, the sole source of leavening, as proof that it is a torte. Still others claim that the separate crust, the soft filling, and the absence of flour prove that it is a custard pie

  • OFFICIALLY IT IS NEITHER, IT IS CLASSIFIEDS IN IT'S OWN SECTION! I looked it up and found it's officially it's own "cheesecake".

    However it is much closer to a pie than a cake. The name has nothing to do with it whatsoever.

    Think of a pumpkin pie or lemon pie. Looks just like a cheesecake.

    When you get right down to it-

    * A cake is made out of a bread-like material, rises when it is baked, and lacks a crust.

    * A pie has some kind of filling, has a crust, and stays the same level when it bakes.

    Those are the official definitions of both.

    A cheesecake fills all the quota for a pie and not one for a cake.

  • Neither. Cheesecake is its own category. It's closer to cake, although it tastes more like pie, but it is neither cake nor pie.

  • it looks more like a pie but its called a cake so i would go with cake just to be safe

  • Pie, even though it has the word cake in it. Do you "cook" cookies? No you bake them. So the name doesn't always match.

  • Since Cheesecake has the word cake in it, I would say it is cake.

  • I make my chocolate comma cakes. I start up with a mix and straight away greater on the recipe via experimenting with greater effective components and toppings, and that they are luscious! i'm no longer a large cookie baker, yet i like to seek around diverse bakeries at holiday cases to discover the yummiest! :)

  • It's not a pie, because pies have like a fruit filling. And it's not a cake because your not frosting it up or using cake batter..

  • actually its considered a CUSTARD. and it is baked in a pie plate therefore it is a pie/custard. its called a cheesecake because cheesepie just sounds wierd.

    I

  • I will say its a cake. It's my favorite cake! :D

Sign In or Register to comment.