It's a fair trade for you if you want power. Fielder will most likely get more homers than Votto and Carpenter isn't a bad option at starting pitching. This trade if even, but since you need Fielder, you should accept it.
Fielder is a stud and I like carpenter, but I say don't do it. I think Votto has gotten his head together and will have a big year. Maybe not quite as good as Fielder, but I think The difference will be closer than the difference between Lincecum and Carpenter. Carpenter has an injury history and now that he is older, I would expect him to miss some time. Lincecum is a freak, and is as safe as any pitcher in the game to guarantee the innings. Close, but keep what you have.
Comments
It's a fair trade for you if you want power. Fielder will most likely get more homers than Votto and Carpenter isn't a bad option at starting pitching. This trade if even, but since you need Fielder, you should accept it.
Fielder is a stud and I like carpenter, but I say don't do it. I think Votto has gotten his head together and will have a big year. Maybe not quite as good as Fielder, but I think The difference will be closer than the difference between Lincecum and Carpenter. Carpenter has an injury history and now that he is older, I would expect him to miss some time. Lincecum is a freak, and is as safe as any pitcher in the game to guarantee the innings. Close, but keep what you have.
Great trade for you if nit a keeper league
Why haven't you completed this trade yet? go for it man