Well they play very different positions.... Salcido is a better defender, but Rafa is a leader & organizer.
Rafa does distribute the ball very well & calmly... but once he gets into the attacking 3rd he doesn't know what to do with the ball... whearas Salcido has a lot of attacking instinct... the goal against Argentina proves it.
Both players deserve alot of respect they are probably the best Mexico has ever produced at their position (Rafa as Libero, and Salcido as Left Back).... Rafa spent many years as one of the 5 best in the world at his position... I think Salcido has a serious shot of being the best Left Back in the world since Roberto Carlos.
I vote for Salcido by a slight margin... but again you can't compare because they play very different roles.
However both have different style of plays, Salcido has more of an attacking style while Marquez is more of a stopper and opens the plays from midfield.
Nery needs more playing time with his club before he wears the green again. Hector Moreno needs to play in Rafa's place. Oscar Rojas for Carlos Salcido. Sabah's in good form right now. Good pick.
They both are great.....Salcido is one of the few Chivas players that I dont hate!! I'm anti-Chiva and Salcido is one of the few players that I like and is a great defence!!! Copa Confederacions 05', him and Osorio were at level that I never seen before....but both Rafa and Salcido have made mistakes that have cost Mexico real bad in important games!!
They play different, but right now Salcido is much better he is captain of his team and Marquez is modeling instead of playing. I love both of they but Salcido at this time is better.
Comments
Rafael Marquez, master of defence. Salcido is not experience as Marquez.
Well they play very different positions.... Salcido is a better defender, but Rafa is a leader & organizer.
Rafa does distribute the ball very well & calmly... but once he gets into the attacking 3rd he doesn't know what to do with the ball... whearas Salcido has a lot of attacking instinct... the goal against Argentina proves it.
Both players deserve alot of respect they are probably the best Mexico has ever produced at their position (Rafa as Libero, and Salcido as Left Back).... Rafa spent many years as one of the 5 best in the world at his position... I think Salcido has a serious shot of being the best Left Back in the world since Roberto Carlos.
I vote for Salcido by a slight margin... but again you can't compare because they play very different roles.
I lik Salcido as a player, but come on of course Rafa Marquez is better.
I think for me is Marquez.
However both have different style of plays, Salcido has more of an attacking style while Marquez is more of a stopper and opens the plays from midfield.
Personality wise I prefer Salcido. Rafa is kind of stuck up but whatever he's a great player. Salcido is great too.
Nery needs more playing time with his club before he wears the green again. Hector Moreno needs to play in Rafa's place. Oscar Rojas for Carlos Salcido. Sabah's in good form right now. Good pick.
Marquez is the best defender, but i still like salcido
They both are great.....Salcido is one of the few Chivas players that I dont hate!! I'm anti-Chiva and Salcido is one of the few players that I like and is a great defence!!! Copa Confederacions 05', him and Osorio were at level that I never seen before....but both Rafa and Salcido have made mistakes that have cost Mexico real bad in important games!!
They play different, but right now Salcido is much better he is captain of his team and Marquez is modeling instead of playing. I love both of they but Salcido at this time is better.
rafael marquez is the second most succesful mexican player in the history of mexico next to hugo sanchez
i mean salcido is very good but rafa is jus something else!!