Francisco Liriano or James Shields?

I would be trading Shields for Liriano

My pitchers right now are:

Cole Hamels

James Shields

Brad Lidge

Jonathan Broxton

Kevin Slowey

Matt Cain

Matt Lindstrom

John Danks

Jair Jurrjens

Andy Sonnanstine

with this roster i definately need more strikeouts

so should i trade shields for liriano?

Comments

  • I think it is a little bit of a gamble because Liriano is a little less proven than Shields, but heck this is a game so go with your gut.

  • i wouldn't trade shields. shields is more proven and will get you at least 5 Ks a game plus wins as well. even if the rays are a fluke this year he will still be getting them wins. plus you could get more value for shields then liriano.

  • Keep Liriano will be really good on this twins squad

  • I prefer Shields, but its a close call

  • shields is btr

Sign In or Register to comment.